This section contains copies of the original binder covers and a table of contents for the entire scrapbook, as well as a foreword and McCutchan's "Who's Who" profiles.

This section is a collection of memorial tributes, both letters to the family and published memorials.

The Early Life section contains newspaper clipping in addition to Helen's biographical narrative.

This section chronicles McCutchan's time as a student, with news clippings, pages from the student publication "The Zenith", and also his marriage certificate to Carrie Sharpe.

This file contains news clippings, music programs, travel documents, photos, letters, and also calling cards from the McCutchans' travels in Europe.

This folder contains letters, news clippings, and programs from McCutchan's time as a faculty member at DePauw University.

This folder contains programs, letters, clippings, and service hymns that were results of commissions and institutes over the course of McCutchan's career, predominantly outside of his capacity as a professor and more reflective of his role as a hymnologist.

This folder includes photographs, programs, news clippings, correspondence, brochures, his marriage certificate to Helen, honorary degree documents, and prayers and readings from his memorial.

Contents include a list of McCutchan's writings, correspondence, news clippings, a service song book, and the dust jackets for several of the books he wrote.

This folder contains a list of hymn tunes by McCutchan, some under his pseudonym John Porter, correspondence, a copyright card, sheet music, and musical sketchbooks.